Australia's High Court Begins Review of Landmark Social Media Ban for Minors
Legal challenges from Reddit and advocacy groups question the constitutionality of restricting online access for children under 16.


PENN Explainer
Hear this story explained in 90 seconds.
The High Court of Australia began hearing arguments this week to determine the legality of a nationwide ban that prevents children under 16 from accessing major social media platforms. The legislation, which took effect in December 2025, requires companies like Facebook, TikTok, and Reddit to implement strict age-verification measures. Platforms that fail to comply with these requirements face potential fines of up to A$99 million. This legal test marks the first major judicial review of the policy since its implementation.
Reddit, one of the primary entities challenging the law, argues that the restrictions are misguided and ineffective. In its submission to the court, the company stated that the ban fails to address the core issues of online safety while simultaneously limiting the ability of young people to engage in digital discourse. Reddit also contends that its platform should be exempt from the rules because it does not rely on the same friend-network structures as other social media sites. Lawyers for the platform described the legislation as ill-conceived and inept during the opening sessions.
A separate constitutional challenge has been brought forward by the Digital Freedom Project, an advocacy group led by New South Wales parliamentarian John Ruddick. The group argues that the ban infringes upon the implied freedom of political communication protected by the Australian Constitution. By barring minors from these digital spaces, the plaintiffs claim the government is effectively censoring young citizens and removing them from important public debates. They argue that the policy is a blunt instrument that disproportionately restricts the rights of young people.
Government officials maintain that the law is a necessary step to protect children from online harms, including predatory algorithms and graphic content. Communications Minister Anika Wells stated outside the court that the policy addresses a critical question regarding what society is willing to accept from technology companies. The government asserts that the burden placed on political communication is modest and justified by the need to safeguard minors. Officials have expressed their intent to defend the legislation throughout the court proceedings.
The effectiveness of the current ban has been a subject of ongoing public debate. Research conducted in June suggested that as many as 80 percent of people under 16 were still accessing social media despite the restrictions. Many users have reportedly bypassed age checks by using credit card details, photo identification, or selfies to verify their status. While millions of accounts were deleted when the law first took effect, critics point to these high usage rates as evidence that the policy is not achieving its intended goals.
Legal experts are closely watching the case to see how the court balances individual rights against the state's interest in child protection. Associate Professor Noam Peleg, an expert in children's rights, noted that the court must consider whether children are being unfairly excluded from exercising their citizenship. He suggested that the case raises fundamental questions about the role of digital platforms in modern society. The outcome of this hearing could influence how other nations approach similar online safety regulations.
As the High Court deliberates, the Australian government is simultaneously pursuing additional legislation to strengthen digital oversight. A proposed digital duty of care bill would place a greater legal responsibility on tech platforms to proactively secure their systems. This new approach would shift the burden away from users reporting harms and toward the companies themselves. The government hopes these measures will provide a more robust framework for managing online safety.
No company has been fined under the current law to date, though the government has signaled a desire to increase penalties for non-compliance. The debate highlights a growing tension between the desire for stricter media regulation and the preservation of open communication channels. As the hearings continue, the court will weigh the evidence provided by both the tech industry and the government. The final ruling is expected to have significant implications for the future of digital policy in Australia and potentially abroad.
You've reached your free article limit
You've read 10 of 10 free articles this month. Subscribe to Planet Earth News Network for unlimited access to neutral, global journalism — plus puzzles, podcasts, and the weekly newsletter.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
Ask the Author
Subscribers can ask the journalist a question about this story. Subscribe to ask.
Neutrality note
Auto-harvested from global news wires and presented neutrally by PENN.
to vote
Comments
No comments yet — be the first to share your thoughts.



